top of page

The Greatest Threat to Islam is Islam

3 minutes ago
18 min read

Logos Incarnate, Logos Inlibrate: Why Christianity Can Repent of the Sword and Islam Cannot


Every religion that enters history will one day be tempted by the sword. The real question is not whether a tradition has ever shed blood in God's name. All of them have. The question is what that tradition has to stand on when it wants to repent.

In The Sword and the Machine I argued that Islam began as a genuine impulse, what Gurdjieff respectfully called the hope of "Saint Mohammed", and then hardened into a mechanical religion of external law. A religion of that kind can only be held together by force: the sword to spread it and the penalty for apostasy to keep it.


The obvious objection to that essay is: what about Christendom? What about the Crusades, the Inquisition, the forced baptisms? It is a fair question, and this essay answers it directly.


My answer is not that Christians behaved better. Often they did not. My answer is that the two traditions are built differently, and the difference lies in where each one locates the Word of God.


In Christianity, the Word became flesh. In Sunni Islam, the Word became a book. Everything else follows from that.


A Christian who takes up the sword must go against his scripture to do it, and so his scripture can always call him back. A Muslim jurist who takes up the sword can go with his scripture, and so the call back has nowhere to stand. That is Islam's dilemma, and it is not one Christianity faces.


This is a claim about structure, not about character. I have known Muslims of deep conscience and Christians with none. The question is what each tradition hands its people when conscience wakes up and asks: was this right?


The Word Made Flesh


"And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us" (John 1:14). For Christians, the final revelation of God is not a text. It is a Person. The scriptures matter because they bear witness to him. Christ says so himself: "Search the scriptures... they are they which testify of me" (John 5:39).


This gives Christianity a key that sits above its own texts. Every passage, including the darkest conquest narratives of Joshua and Judges, is read through the face of Christ. The Church did not invent this method to escape embarrassment. Christ taught it. In the Sermon on the Mount he quotes the Law and then overrules its letter on his own authority: "Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye... But I say unto you, That ye resist not evil" (Matthew 5:38–39).


And on the sword, he leaves no room at all:


  • When James and John want to call down fire on a Samaritan village that refused them, he rebukes them: "Ye know not what manner of spirit ye are of" (Luke 9:55, KJV; some early manuscripts lack these words).

  • When Peter draws his sword in Gethsemane, the answer is: "Put up again thy sword into his place: for all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword" (Matthew 26:52).

  • Before Pilate, the principle is stated outright: "My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight" (John 18:36).


Nowhere in the New Testament is a Christian commanded to fight unbelievers, to impose the faith by force, or to kill an apostate. The rich young ruler walks away from Christ, and Christ lets him go (Mark 10:22). When many disciples leave, he turns to the Twelve and asks only: "Will ye also go away?" (John 6:67). The door out is left open, because the only faith he wants is faith freely given.


This is the decisive fact. Whatever Christians later did with the sword, they had to find their justification somewhere other than the Gospels. And because the Gospels stayed at the centre of worship, read aloud at every liturgy, the indictment of Christian violence was read aloud with them.


The Word Made Book


Islam also has a doctrine of the eternal Word. Sunni orthodoxy holds that the Qur'an is the uncreated speech of God (kalam Allah), existing with Him from eternity and inscribed on the Preserved Tablet before it was ever recited in Mecca. The Harvard scholar Harry Wolfson, in The Philosophy of the Kalam, studied this doctrine closely, and the word scholars now use for it is often credited to him. As Christians speak of the incarnation of the Word, Muslims could be said to believe in its inlibration: the Word made book.


The parallel is clear, and so is the difference. Where Christianity places a Person at the summit of revelation, Islam places a text. And a text cannot stand above itself.

This is why the Qur'an has no key outside its own pages. There is no Christ through whom to read the Medinan chapters. The Prophet is honoured as the final messenger, but his example (sunna) only adds more law to the law: the hadith collections of Bukhari and Muslim become a second body of binding text, and among them stand the reports commanding the Prophet to fight until people bear witness, and the bare instruction that whoever changes his religion should be killed.


Instead of a key above the text, classical Islam developed a principle within it: abrogation (naskh), by which a later verse cancels an earlier one. The early Meccan verses counsel patience with unbelievers, and the famous verse "there is no compulsion in religion" (2:256) comes from the early Medinan period.


But the later chapters bring the verse of the sword (9:5) and the command to fight the People of the Book until they pay the jizya in submission (9:29). Some classical writers on abrogation claimed that 9:5 alone cancelled 124 earlier verses of patience and tolerance.


Others, such as al-Suyuti, counted only about twenty abrogated verses in the whole Qur'an and read 9:5 in its context. But where the abrogation reading prevailed, the choice between the texts ran toward the sword.


I want to be fair to my Muslim readers here. Many sincere Muslims read the fighting verses as defensive and bound to the wars of seventh-century Arabia, and they hold 2:256 as the abiding principle. I honour that reading. But notice what it has to do. It has to argue against the weight of the classical schools of law.


The Christian who rejects holy war is standing on the words of Christ. The Muslim who rejects it is standing against much of his own jurisprudence, and he has no higher authority in his tradition to appeal to.

The Door That Closed


It did not have to be this way, and Islam's own history demonstrates it.


In the eighth and ninth centuries a school of theologians called the Mu'tazila argued that the Qur'an was created. God's speech, they said, was an act of God in time, not an eternal attribute alongside Him. They compared it to the voice God created in the burning bush to speak to Moses. Whatever their motives, the implication was enormous.


A created Qur'an is a Qur'an addressed to a particular people at a particular moment. Its rulings could be weighed against the circumstances that called them forth. It could be read, in a word, the way Christians read the Law of Moses: as true revelation, but not the final word.


For a brief period the Mu'tazila had the backing of the state. Under the caliph al-Ma'mun, from 833, judges and scholars were examined on the question in an inquisition known as the mihna. Ahmad ibn Hanbal, whose teaching gave rise to the most traditionalist of the four Sunni law schools, refused to confess a created Qur'an and was flogged for it under al-Ma'mun's successor, al-Mu'tasim. Between about 847 and 851 the caliph al-Mutawakkil reversed the policy. Ibn Hanbal became a hero of orthodoxy, and the uncreated Qur'an became the settled doctrine of Sunni Islam.


There is a bitter irony here. The one school that might have given Islam a way to set its own texts in context also tried to impose its view by force. It lost, and with it went the theological ground on which a reform could have stood. What remained was an eternal text that cannot be contextualised without being diminished, and a body of law built on that text that cannot be revised without the charge of tampering with the speech of God.


That is the dilemma in its plainest form. To reform Islam's teaching on the sword, a Muslim must either say that some of God's eternal words no longer apply, or find a reading so strained that the classical jurists would not recognise it. Christianity never has to make that choice. It only has to return to Christ.

The Sword Taken Up Against the Gospel


Now to Christendom.


The Crusades did not come from nowhere. By 1095 four centuries of conquest had taken the Christian heartlands of Syria, Palestine, Egypt, North Africa and much of Spain. After the Seljuk victory at Manzikert in 1071, most of Anatolia fell. In March 1095 envoys of the Byzantine emperor Alexios I Komnenos came to the Council of Piacenza to ask the West for help.


Historians such as Thomas Madden argue that the First Crusade was, in its origins, a defensive response to that pressure, and Jonathan Riley-Smith documented how many of the first crusaders named the relief of eastern Christians as their reason for going. Others, notably Thomas Asbridge, doubt there was any compelling external cause, so the question is still argued among scholars. Raymond Ibrahim has made the same case for a wider readership in Sword and Scimitar.


But Gurdjieff does not let us off so easily. For him war is not wrong only when it is aggressive. It is an abnormality in the cosmos, the clearest sign of mankind's sleep. And the deeper fault of the Crusades was not that Christians fought. It was that they made fighting holy.

At Clermont in November 1095, Urban II declared that the armed pilgrimage would count in place of all penance. Earlier popes had made gestures in this direction, but Clermont made it the rallying cry of a whole civilisation: killing in battle became a way to work off sin. That is the structure condemned in The Sword and the Machine: the sanctification of war. A defensive cause does not redeem it.


And the sanctified sword did what the machine always does. It turned on whatever stood nearest:


  • In 1096, crusading bands massacred the Jewish communities of the Rhineland.

  • In 1099, the taking of Jerusalem ended in the slaughter of its Muslim and Jewish inhabitants.

  • In 1147, Bernard of Clairvaux urged the crusade against the pagan Wends east of the Elbe to go on until they were either converted or wiped out. That is compulsion in religion as naked as anything in the fiqh.

  • In 1204, the Fourth Crusade sacked Christian Constantinople and desecrated Hagia Sophia.


Where did the justification come from? Not from the Gospels. It came from the Old Testament wars, read as though Christ had not come. It came from Roman ideas of just war.


And it came from scripture twisted out of shape, as when Augustine took the words of a parable, "compel them to come in" (Luke 14:23), and turned them into a warrant for using imperial force against the Donatists. A feast invitation became a licence for coercion. That is what it costs to get a sword out of the Gospels: you have to break them first.


The Church That Would Not Bless the Sword


If Christianity's self-correction were only theoretical, my argument would be weak. It is not theoretical. One whole branch of the Church refused to make war holy, and it refused on the authority of its Fathers.


In the fourth century, St Basil the Great wrote a series of canonical letters that became part of the Orthodox Church's law. In his thirteenth canon he addresses soldiers who have killed in war. The Fathers before him, he says, did not count this as murder, making allowance for men who fought in defence of chastity and true religion. Yet he advises that they keep away from Holy Communion for three years, because their hands are not clean. Killing might sometimes be necessary. It was never holy. A man returning from even a just war came back as a penitent, not a hero.


Six centuries later that canon faced a real test. The emperor Nikephoros II Phokas, called the "White Death of the Saracens", was the greatest Byzantine general of his age. He conquered Crete, Cilicia and much of Syria from Muslim rulers. He was a man of real piety, closely tied to the monks of Mount Athos. During his reign (963–969) he asked the Church to honour soldiers who had fallen fighting Muslims as martyrs. It was, in effect, a request for the crusade four generations before Clermont, and it came from an emperor at the height of his power.


The Church said no. According to the chronicler John Skylitzes, Patriarch Polyeuktos and the bishops answered by citing Basil's canon. How could men be counted martyrs when the Church's own law barred those who had shed blood from communion for three years? The emperor gave up the plan.


This is the self-correcting mechanism working in history. The Greek East faced Islamic armies for longer and at closer range than any Western kingdom ever did. It had every reason to want a theology of holy war, and it never adopted one. When the crusading West finally came east in 1204, it was Orthodox Christians who suffered under the cross on Latin shields.


The Orthodox did not refuse because they were gentler or less threatened. They refused because the patristic mind was formed by the Gospels and would not call blessed what Christ had called perishing (Matthew 26:52).


The Reformer They Hanged


Is Islamic reform then impossible? Not in the imagination. One of the bravest religious thinkers of the twentieth century showed exactly how it might be done, and what it costs.


Mahmoud Mohamed Taha was a Sudanese engineer and mystic, born in 1909. After a long period of religious seclusion he developed what he called The Second Message of Islam.


His proposal was simple and daring: reverse the abrogation. The Meccan verses, with their freedom of conscience and their equality of persons, were the universal and eternal message of Islam. The Medinan verses, with their law codes, their fighting and their unequal status for women and non-Muslims, were concessions suited to seventh-century Arabia. Taha believed humanity had now grown ready for the first message. Sharia, he argued, should be rebuilt on the Meccan Qur'an.


Notice what Taha had to do. He had no Christ above the text to appeal to. So he split the text in two and set one half over the other, reversing the classical order of abrogation. It was the nearest thing to a Logos that the Qur'an alone could supply.


In January 1985, after he distributed leaflets against the imposition of sharia in Sudan, Taha was arrested and tried for apostasy. Several of his followers were condemned with him; they recanted and were spared. Taha, in his mid-seventies, would not recant. On 18 January 1985 he was hanged in Khartoum under the regime of Gaafar Nimeiry.


His death tells us two things. First, a path of reform within Islam can be imagined, and a Muslim imagined it. Second, the law he was trying to reform answered him with the very penalty he was trying to abolish. The apostasy law that keeps the machine closed was used to kill the man who tried to open it.


I write this with respect for Taha and for the Muslims who honour him today, including his student Abdullahi Ahmed An-Na'im, who translated The Second Message into English and has carried the argument on. They are the readers I most hope will hear this essay. I am not saying that a Muslim cannot be a man of conscience. Taha proves he can. I am saying that the system he belonged to treated his conscience as a capital crime.


Conscience Needs a Face


Why should it matter so much whether the Word is a Person or a book? Gurdjieff gives us the language to answer.


As elaborated in Remorse of Conscience: the sacred agony that transforms the Soul, Gurdjieff, as Ouspensky recorded it, sees morality and conscience are opposites.


Morality is a set of external rules. It differs from country to country and age to age, and it is entirely mechanical: a man obeys it without ever waking up.


Conscience is something else. It has nothing in common with morality, and it is not a rule at all. It is the state in which a person feels at once everything he feels and knows, all his contradictions, without the buffers that normally keep them apart. In Beelzebub's Tales, Gurdjieff calls this Objective Conscience, the last divine impulse left in man, buried in the subconscious and awakened only through intentional suffering.


A law code, however holy, is a form of morality. It can be obeyed in sleep. It can be applied by a machine. This is why a religion of law tends toward the sword: when obedience is mechanical, it must be enforced from outside, because nothing inside the follower is awake enough to hold it. That was the feedback loop I traced in The Sword and the Machine.


Conscience, by contrast, cannot be written down, because it is always a meeting with a living presence. That is what Christianity offers in place of a code. When a Christian soldier stands over the body of his enemy, his scripture does not hand him a ruling. It shows him a face: the Christ who healed the ear of the servant Peter had struck (Luke 22:51), who prayed for those nailing him to the cross (Luke 23:34). You cannot argue with that face. You can only look at it and be judged.


This is why a Person can correct his followers in a way a text cannot. A text can be interpreted to say almost anything, and every jurist knows it. But a Person has a character. Every Christian who has ever wanted to bless the sword has had to look away from Christ to do it. And every Christian who has repented of it, from Basil's penitent soldiers to Polyeuktos facing down his emperor, has done so by looking back.


The Muslim of conscience has no such face to turn to. He has the Prophet, but the Prophet of the hadith led armies and is reported to have commanded the death of apostates. He has the Qur'an, but it speaks with two voices, and the tradition settled long ago which voice wins. His conscience may be awake, as Taha's was, but it has nothing in his tradition with authority over the law. It has to stand alone against the whole structure. In Gurdjieff's terms, it is a single awakened impulse set against an entire machine.


The Sword Turns Inward


If the dilemma cannot be solved from within, where does it leave Islam? Christ already answered the question: "all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword" (Matthew 26:52). A sword blessed for use against the unbeliever does not stay pointed outward. When the unbelievers run out, it finds new ones inside.


The mechanism is simple. A law that kills the apostate needs a way to decide who is an apostate. Islam developed one: takfir, the act of declaring a professing Muslim to be an unbeliever. Once that power exists, every quarrel over doctrine or power can be settled by it. The opponent is not merely wrong. He has left Islam, and his blood is lawful. This is the machine at its purest: a judgment applied from outside, with no conscience left to stop it.


We do not have to imagine where this leads. It began in the first generation:


  • Of the four "Rightly Guided" caliphs, three were assassinated. Umar was stabbed by a Persian slave, an outsider with a private grievance. The next two deaths came from within. Uthman was killed by Muslim rebels in 656, and his death set off the first civil war, the fitna.

  • Out of that war came the Kharijites, the first sect in Islam. They declared Ali and everyone who accepted arbitration with his rival to be unbelievers, and in 661 one of them, Ibn Muljam, struck Ali down while he was at prayer.

  • The quarrel over succession hardened into the Sunni–Shia division, what Gurdjieff called the "organic hate" between them, which still sheds blood fourteen centuries later.


The pattern has never stopped. Many Sunni scholars today describe ISIS and similar groups as neo-Kharijites, because they too declare other Muslims unbelievers and kill them. And the dead bear this out.


In 2011 the US National Counterterrorism Center reported that, where the religion of terrorism victims could be determined, Muslims made up between 82 and 97 percent of them. Researchers rightly note that much of this violence has political roots. But politics alone does not explain why the killers can call it holy. That permission comes from the law.


Some readers will draw the conclusion to its end: that if Islam ever conquered the world, it would have no outsiders left, and would turn the whole of its sword upon itself, death begetting death until nothing remained.

I do not offer that as a prophecy. History rarely runs so cleanly, and the future is in God's hands, not in our extrapolations. But the thought experiment shows the logic of the machine. It does not need a world empire to begin devouring itself. It has been doing so since the death of Uthman. Gurdjieff's name for war was "the process of reciprocal destruction", and a religion that sanctifies it will practise it on its own members as readily as on strangers.


So where does this leave Islam? I see three paths.


  1. The machine continues. The law stays sovereign, takfir stays available, and each generation produces its own Kharijites. The sword keeps turning inward.

  2. Quiet erosion. Millions of Muslims already live peaceably by setting the harsh rulings aside in practice without ever renouncing them in principle. This is humane, and I honour it. But it is unstable, because the rulings remain on the books for the next zealot to revive. Peace that rests on the law being ignored is not reform.

  3. The way of conscience. This is the path of the dervishes Gurdjieff respected, and of Taha. It means finding something higher than the letter of the law. The tragedy is that, within Islam's own structure, that higher authority has nowhere to stand. Which is why I return, in the end, to the One the Qur'an itself calls the Word.


None of this is a curse on Muslims. Muslims are the first victims of the machine, not its authors. It is a description of what the sword does to any people who bless it, Christians included, and Christendom's own wars of religion show it. The difference is that Christians can lay the sword down in obedience to their Lord. For Muslims, laying it down has always meant going beyond the law, and too often it has meant death.


The Verdict


Christendom has more blood on its hands than Christians like to admit. The Crusades were a real response to real conquest, but they were also a real betrayal. They made holy what Christ had forbidden, and the sword they blessed turned on Jews, pagans and finally on Orthodox Christians. I make no defence of that.


But Christianity has always carried its own indictment inside it. Every Christian war had to be justified from outside the Gospels, and the Gospels never stopped being read. That is why St Basil could set penance for soldiers, why Patriarch Polyeuktos could refuse an emperor, and why the West itself eventually repented of the crusading ideal. When Christianity returns to its source, it returns to the One who said "put up thy sword". Its reformation is always a return.


Islam faces a harder road. Its source is a book held to be the eternal and uncreated speech of God, and that book, together with the Prophet's example, sanctions the sword, the jizya and the penalty for apostasy. For Islam, a return to the source is a return to Medina. That is why the reformers have had to go beyond the classical tradition rather than back to it, and why the most courageous of them was hanged for apostasy. This is a real dilemma, and it is not one Christians face. To deny it is no kindness to Muslims. It is a refusal to take their faith seriously.


To My Muslim Readers


There is one more thing I want to say to my Muslim readers, because the Qur'an itself says it. It calls Jesus, the son of Mary, God's word and a spirit from Him (4:171).


In Islam's own book there is a hint that the Word might be more than a book. I do not ask Muslims to give up their faith to hear this. I ask only that they consider the One their own scripture calls the Word, who rebuked his disciples for wanting fire from heaven, and who would not let his servants fight to save him.


And to the Muslim reader who has read this far and found that it describes something you already feel, the unease when you hear the verses of the sword recited, the dread at what your community would do to someone who left: that unease is not betrayal. It is conscience, the most precious thing God has placed in you, refusing to fall asleep.


You are not the first Muslim to feel it. The dervishes kept it alive for centuries, and Taha gave his life for it. You do not have to resolve everything at once, and no one has the right to force you.


Nicodemus came to Christ by night, when he could not yet come by day, and Christ did not turn him away (John 3:2). He does not compel anyone. He says only, "Behold, I stand at the door, and knock: if any man hear my voice, and open the door, I will come in to him, and will sup with him, and he with me" (Revelation 3:20). The door is yours to open, in your own time.


The sword serves the machine. The Word made flesh is the way out of it.

Sources


Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

©2021 by Soul Creation

bottom of page